Data Mining Dutch Football

Data Mining Dutch Football

Problem being addressed

Can a useful forecasting model for football games be built using a combination of machine learning methods and publicly available data?

Solution

The authors use publicly available data on the Dutch Football League to develop a predictive model that aims to forecast the outcome of a given match. Typical publicly available data includes travel distance between matches, results over a rolling period, results from the previous season and disruptions to the coaching and playing staff. A set of 45 data features is used by the authors, and these features are used to train and evaluate different machine learning methods including Random Forest and Naive Bayes.

Advantages of this solution

There researchers conclude that there is statistically no difference between using publicly available data (over a 13 year period) and looking at betting odds. This isn't really a spectacular predictive result, but it confirms that if you would like to genuinely do better than the odds, then you would need to look at more sophisticated machine learning modelling than using publicly available data.

Solution originally applied in these industries

entertainment

Entertainment Industry

sports

Sports Industry

Possible New Application of the Work

/static/media/automotive-1.2524d1c6.png

Automotive Industry

Secondary vehicle markets are interesting because they give an indication of the durability of a vehicle. Cars that don't break are often resold. This data is available on the web from car sales websites. An interesting project would be to predict the reliability of a brand (in a given country) based on sales in the secondary car market, and data points like vehicle mileage.



Real Estate Industry

There is a great deal of publicly available data in the real-estate industry. It would be interesting to build similar predictors for consumers that are looking to buy; it may help them decide where and when to enter the market. And, it could be a better guide than an agent.

Author of original research described in this blitzcard:

question-mark-icon

Name of the author who conducted the original research that this blitzcard is based on.

Source DOI: #############check-icon


search-iconBrowse all blitzcards